When Artificial Intelligence takes Leadership
Enterprise Leadership 5.0
April 11, 2025
Our NET.story Fact or Myth?
Will AI Take Over Leadership Roles? Opportunities, Potentials, and Risks for Executives
In an increasingly digitised world, businesses face a crucial question: Can artificial intelligence (AI) eventually take over leadership tasks? Will it be able to replace human leaders, or at least support them in their roles? And what opportunities and risks does the use of AI in leadership positions hold? In this NET.story episode, we explore how AI can assist executives and where its limitations lie when it comes to the "human" side of leadership.
AI as a Support Tool in Leadership Tasks
Already today, AI is an indispensable tool for many executives and entrepreneurs. It supports the automation of routine tasks, aids in analysing large datasets, and enables well-informed decisions based on real-time information. Particularly in the area of data analysis, AI offers a huge advantage: It detects patterns that often remain invisible to humans and helps anticipate market trends and optimise business strategies.
Another example is the optimisation of business processes. AI-based systems are increasingly taking on tasks such as inventory management, production planning, or automating customer support requests. In areas like personnel management or financial analysis, AI helps executives make quick, efficient decisions based on precise, data-driven forecasts.
Opportunities and Potential of AI in Leadership Roles
The potential of AI in leadership positions is promising. It can contribute significantly to improving the efficiency of a business by taking over time-consuming, repetitive tasks, giving leaders more time for strategic thinking and innovation.
Personalised leadership through AI is another exciting potential. AI tools can provide leaders with detailed insights into employee talent and performance, enabling them to create customised development plans. By analysing individual strengths and weaknesses, AI can help leaders focus on the specific needs of their teams and foster their growth over the long term.
AI could also act as a driving force behind innovation and new business models. By analysing data and identifying market opportunities, AI can develop new ideas and help companies implement disruptive business strategies. Another benefit is that AI can help minimise biases in decision-making, enabling more objective evaluations that are not influenced by human biases.
The Possibility of AI Taking Over Leadership Roles
There are already efforts where AI is stepping into a leadership role — whether as a virtual CEO, making decisions in certain areas, or as an automated advisor, supporting leaders in strategic considerations. In the future, AI systems could become even more autonomous, making significant decisions on their own.
However, the question remains whether AI can truly take over the complex and interpersonal aspects of leadership. While AI excels in data-driven fields such as financial management or logistics, it lacks the ability to empathise and take emotional factors into account, which are indispensable for successful leadership.
Should AI Be Seen as a Tool for Humans or as a Human Substitute?
A central question when integrating AI into leadership roles is whether it should be viewed as a tool for humans or as a substitute for human leaders. When used as a tool, AI means that it supports the leader by analysing data, predicting trends, and suggesting solutions. In this case, the human leader remains the decisive actor, making the final decisions and leading the employees.
If AI is viewed as a substitute for humans, it could lead to a scenario where machines gradually take over leadership tasks. This not only raises technical and organisational questions but also ethical and social ones. Should a machine, which has no emotions, be held responsible for the well-being of employees? And how will we handle the impact on trust and employee motivation?
Risks and Dangers of AI in Leadership Roles
Despite its many advantages, the use of AI in leadership positions also poses significant risks and dangers. One key issue is the lack of emotional intelligence. Good leaders are not only technically proficient but also skilled at communicating emotionally with their employees, building trust, and responding empathetically in challenging situations. AI, on the other hand, cannot demonstrate empathy or build relationships, which makes it a poor substitute for humans in emotionally complex situations.
Another risk is accountability: Who is responsible if an AI makes a wrong decision? In a company heavily reliant on AI, legal and ethical problems could arise if decisions are no longer traceable or based on discrimination or biases. There are also fundamental ethical questions: How do we address possible biases in AI algorithms, which may be based on flawed or one-sided training data?
Moreover, there is the risk that companies might become overly dependent on AI systems, losing the flexibility and creativity that human leaders bring. A complete reliance on AI could undermine a company's ability to innovate and adapt quickly in dynamic business environments.
The Employee Perspective: How Do People React to AI-Driven Leadership?
Another critical aspect is how employees will react to increasingly AI-driven leadership. Many people prefer to be led by a human leader who understands their values, addresses their needs, and builds a personal relationship. An AI that shows no emotions might lead to mistrust and a loss of motivation. Employees could feel less understood and perceive that their individual needs are not being considered in decisions.
A further critical point is the acceptance of AI as a leadership entity. While technological advances are welcomed in many areas of work, the idea of being led by a machine could create discomfort among many employees. How transparent and understandable AI's decisions are will be crucial in building trust in the system.
The Individuality and USP of a Company: What Happens When AI Takes Over Leadership?
An often overlooked aspect is that the individuality of a company and its Unique Selling Proposition (USP) are often deeply rooted in the people who lead it. The values, visions, and cultural orientation of a company are shaped by the leadership and their personal experiences, beliefs, and interactions with employees and partners. This authentic influence is what gives a company its unique identity and sets it apart from others.
In theory, AI could help standardise processes and make decisions more objective, but it cannot easily integrate cultural nuances, personalities, or ethical principles. Will leadership by AI eventually lead to a homogenisation and standardisation of corporate cultures – a "one-size-fits-all" approach that blurs the distinctive and unique qualities of companies? Every leader brings their own values, creative vision, and personal style – elements that AI can hardly replicate.
The Human Component of the Leader
Despite all technological advancements, the human component remains one of the most important pillars of effective leadership. A good leader requires not only analytical skills but also emotional intelligence: the ability to understand the emotions and needs of employees, motivate them, and make the right decisions in difficult situations.
Creativity and vision are other aspects that AI can hardly replace. The ability to generate new ideas and steer a company toward the future is often based on the personal experiences, intuition, and imagination of a leader – qualities that machines simply do not possess.
Moreover, the leader also carries immense responsibility for the decisions they make. Ethics and morality remain crucial for long-term success as a company. AI cannot take on responsibility or make ethical considerations – that duty remains with humans.
Conclusion: Responsible Use of AI – An Invitation to Reflect
AI offers enormous opportunities to support leaders in their daily work and optimise processes. It can increase efficiency, facilitate data-driven decisions, and even inspire innovation. Yet, the emotional intelligence, creativity, and ethical responsibility that human leaders provide cannot be so easily replaced by machines. The question remains: How much of the human component of leadership should and can be left to machines?
It is essential that we are aware of the potentials and risks when integrating AI into leadership roles. How do we handle the responsibility that comes with using AI? Who is liable if an AI makes a wrong or discriminatory decision? Can we ensure that AI does not lose the ethical and cultural values that shape our relationships with others?
We invite you to think about this: Do you see AI as a valuable tool that supports humans, or a potential substitute for human leadership and responsibility? Will AI enrich the individuality of a company, or will it lead to a "one-size-fits-all" approach that blurs the unique? How will you, as an entrepreneur or leader, design the use of AI to take advantage of technological progress while preserving the human perspective?
The path to digital transformation is irreversible – and it holds enormous opportunities for innovation and growth. Yet, in all this progress, we should never forget that common sense, humility, and our awareness of humanity and nature are indispensable. Technology should serve humans, not the other way around. AI can take over many tasks, but the profound decisions, ethical considerations, and nurturing of relationships still require the human at the top.
Embrace the opportunities of the digital world, but always remember that the true strength of a company lies not in the machine, but in the human who leads with empathy, responsibility, and a clear vision. We should continue to hold onto the values that unite us as a society and not let machines replace them. The future of work will be one where humans and machines work hand in hand – but humans remain the decision-makers.
Enterprise Leadership News: Facts or Myths – Your weekly dose of leadership excursion
Each week, we curate relevant articles and statements from around the web on the topic of Enterprise Leadership, creating inspiring, thought-provoking, and sometimes even provocative content. We take a step back with our own commentary, encouraging personal reflection. We present common assumptions and biased claims – facts or myths? It's up to you to form your own opinion and draw your own conclusions.
For entrepreneurs and executives who are looking for something beyond carefully crafted advice, blueprints, and mainstream clichés: This newsletter is designed to provide variety, inspiration, and a shift in perspective, helping you shape your leadership strategies in a successful and informed way.
Get your weekly dose of leadership excursion here!
Enterneering® APP ❘ Free Download
 |  |
Step 1: Download the app from your app store for free on mobile devices.
Step 2: Sign-up your profile for free using the menu at the top right of the app's header on the mobile device used for the download.
Enjoy unlimited access to our NET.story episodes by using your app profile on any internet-connected device.
